TL;DR
Apartment Therapy contributors tested more than 50 West Elm rugs in person at a New York City store and organized their recommendations by design and practical use. Their guide compares rugs using five criteria, including feel, pile height and versatility; product prices and details may change.
Apartment Therapy contributors tested more than 50 West Elm rugs in person at a New York City store and published recommendations for shoppers weighing style, texture and household needs. The guide offers a way to compare the retailer’s broad rug selection, including a featured medium-pile Lumini Performance Wool Rug described by the testers as a low-maintenance neutral option.
Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The testers, contributor Nikol Slatinska and shopping writer Megan Gray, assessed rugs in store and revisited the selection. Their review uses five criteria: in-store placement, aesthetic, feel, pile height and versatility. The criteria are intended to help shoppers connect a rug’s characteristics to where and how it will be used, rather than choosing by appearance alone.
The Lumini Performance Wool Rug is one example in the guide. Apartment Therapy describes it as 65% wool, with a dense, ribbed, medium-height pile and four neutral color options. The listing gives sizes from 3-by-5 feet to 10-by-14 feet, along with several runner dimensions. The article says its restrained design may suit varied decor, while shoppers seeking a bolder pattern may prefer another pick.
The source also lists a limited-time offer for the Faceted Tile Performance Rug: $559.20, reduced from $699, for a promotion scheduled to run from Wednesday, November 18, through Sunday, November 22. It labels this an early Black Friday deal. The source says prices were accurate at publication, not that they are guaranteed to remain available.
Choose a West Elm rug for your space
Apartment Therapy contributors assessed more than 50 rugs in person. Their criteria help shoppers weigh style, feel and everyday use.
How the guide compares rugs
The editors considered both appearance and practical details that photos may not show.
Consider whether the rug suits a busy or quieter area.
Compare color, pattern, texture and pile height.
Check layering, indoor or outdoor use, reversibility, sizes and colors.
A neutral option: Lumini
The featured medium-pile rug is described as a low-maintenance choice for varied decor.
Dense, ribbed pile
The rug is 65% wool and has a medium-height pile.
Neutral colors and sizes
Four neutral colors; sizes run from 3-by-5 to 10-by-14 feet, plus runners.
Match features to the room
Choose what matters most for how the space is used.
- Prioritize easier care and practical use.
- Check material and cleaning guidance.
- Give more weight to softness or a distinctive pattern.
- Consider how the rug fits the decor.
Check details before buying
The supplied excerpt does not confirm current prices or availability.
- Verify current price, dimensions, material and care instructions.
- Ask about complimentary material swatches and design guidance.
- Do not assume the listed Faceted Tile promotion is still active.
Match Rug Features to Daily Use
Rugs can shape how a room looks and feels, but their practical features matter too. A household with frequent foot traffic may prioritize a surface that is easier to maintain, while someone furnishing a quieter room may put more weight on softness or a distinctive pattern. Apartment Therapy’s categories give readers a consistent framework for comparing those trade-offs.
The guide also addresses a common shopping limitation: rugs can be difficult to judge from product photographs alone. The contributors’ in-store assessment provides observations about texture and pile that a screen may not convey. Those findings are still editorial judgments, not a guarantee that a rug will perform the same way in every home or under every cleaning routine.
Price is another practical consideration. The source notes that West Elm rugs can be expensive depending on size, and its listed sale price applies to one model during a stated promotional window. Shoppers should check current prices, dimensions, materials and care instructions before buying.
Products Worth Considering

Shark PowerDetect Robot Vacuum and Mop Combo with 60-Day Self-Emptying Base (AV2800ZE)

Roborock Qrevo S Pro Robot Vacuum and Mop with 18,500 Pa Suction

Sony BRAVIA 5 85-Inch Mini LED 4K HDR Smart Google TV (K-85XR50)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Editors Tested Rugs
The guide is part of Apartment Therapy’s Personal Shopper series, which presents editor-tested home products. According to the source, Slatinska and Gray have tested furniture and decor for the series, and Gray recently visited the New York City West Elm store to reassess the rugs’ design, pile and durability.
The in-store placement criterion considers whether a rug is displayed in a high-traffic part of the store or in a quieter area. The aesthetic assessment considers color, pattern and how strongly a rug might stand out among other decor. Feel and pile height address surface texture and thickness, while versatility covers factors such as indoor or outdoor use, layering, reversibility, and available sizes and colors.
Apartment Therapy says it independently selects products and may earn a commission if readers buy through its links. The supplied article excerpt includes details about the Lumini rug and the Faceted Tile promotion, but only the beginning of its entry for the Kai Flatweave Rug. It does not provide enough information here to summarize the full set of tested recommendations.
“The guide evaluates rugs by “In-Store Placement,” “Aesthetic,” “Feel,” “Fluff Factor” and “Versatility.””
— Apartment Therapy
Prices and Performance May Vary
The source does not state the year for the November 18–22 sale dates in the supplied excerpt, and the listed offer may have expired or changed. Current product availability, pricing, color choices and dimensions are not confirmed here. Shoppers should check West Elm’s current listing before relying on the promotion or product specifications.
The testers’ assessments were made in a store, and the source does not describe long-term, in-home testing or provide standardized durability results. It also does not include the full review entries for every rug mentioned in the article’s contents. The available material therefore supports a description of the testing method and selected findings, but not a complete ranking of all West Elm rugs.
Check Current Listings Before Buying
Readers considering a specific rug can compare its current dimensions, material composition, care guidance and price with the needs of the room. The source says West Elm offers complimentary material swatches and design guidance, which may help shoppers assess colors and finishes before ordering. The next step for anyone interested in the Faceted Tile offer is to verify whether the promotion is still active; its stated dates alone do not establish current availability.
Key Questions
How many West Elm rugs did Apartment Therapy test?
Apartment Therapy says its contributors tested more than 50 rugs in person at a West Elm store in New York City.
What criteria did the testers use?
The guide considers store placement, appearance, feel, pile height and versatility, including whether a rug is suitable for layering or indoor and outdoor use.
What does the source say about the Lumini Performance Wool Rug?
The source describes it as a 65% wool rug with a dense, ribbed, medium pile and four neutral colors. It lists sizes from 3-by-5 feet to 10-by-14 feet, plus runner sizes, and characterizes the rug as relatively easy to clean.
Is the Faceted Tile rug discount still available?
The source lists a price of $559.20, down from $699, for November 18–22, but it does not establish whether the offer remains active. Check the retailer’s current listing for availability and pricing.
Source: apartmenttherapy.com
