Connect with us

Beginners Guides

Does Boiling Vinegar Clean the Air



boiling vinegar for air purification

So, you've heard that boiling vinegar can miraculously cleanse the air, but is there any truth to this claim?

Well, let's just say the answer might surprise you.

We all strive for a clean and healthy living environment, and if boiling vinegar could potentially help achieve that, it's worth exploring further.

But before you grab your pot and vinegar, there are a few important things to consider.

Key Takeaways

  • Boiling vinegar releases acetic acid and other volatile compounds into the air, potentially contributing to air cleanliness.
  • The volatile compounds released from heated vinegar may neutralize unpleasant odors and interact with airborne particles, potentially improving air quality.
  • Boiling vinegar can release steam, which might help control indoor humidity levels.
  • The effectiveness of vinegar in purifying the air requires further scientific investigation.

The Science Behind Boiling Vinegar

Boiling vinegar releases acetic acid and other volatile compounds into the air, which can potentially impact indoor air quality. When vinegar is heated, chemical reactions occur, causing the acetic acid to vaporize and mix with the surrounding air. This process may lead to a temporary change in air composition, but the effectiveness of this method in purifying the air is still under debate.

Chemical reactions taking place during the boiling of vinegar result in the release of acetic acid vapor, which has the potential to react with other compounds present in the air. While acetic acid is known for its antimicrobial properties, its ability to purify the air when boiled isn't well-documented. Furthermore, the production of acetic acid vapor during this process may not be sufficient to significantly impact air quality, especially in larger indoor spaces.


Potential Benefits of Boiling Vinegar

vinegar boiling health benefits

Research suggests that the potential benefits of heating vinegar may include the release of volatile compounds that could interact with airborne particles. Vinegar, primarily composed of acetic acid, has properties that enable it to act as a disinfectant and deodorizer. When heated, these properties are enhanced, potentially aiding in air purification. However, it is essential to note that while heating vinegar may release volatile compounds, the effectiveness of these compounds in purifying the air is subject to further scientific investigation.

Potential BenefitsExplanation
DisinfectionVinegar's acetic acid content can help kill certain bacteria and viruses, potentially contributing to air cleanliness.
DeodorizationThe release of volatile compounds from heated vinegar may assist in neutralizing unpleasant odors, thereby improving air quality.
Airborne Particle InteractionVolatile compounds released during heating may have the ability to interact with airborne particles, potentially reducing their presence in the air.
Humidity ControlHeating vinegar can lead to the release of steam, which might help in controlling indoor humidity levels.

Safety Considerations When Boiling Vinegar

After conducting a thorough review of the potential risks associated with heating vinegar, it's crucial to address the safety considerations when engaging in this practice.

When boiling vinegar, proper ventilation is essential to prevent the inhalation of potentially harmful vapors. The acrid odor of heated vinegar can be overpowering, and prolonged exposure may cause respiratory irritation. Therefore, it's advisable to conduct this activity in a well-ventilated area or use a fume hood to minimize the risk of inhalation.

Additionally, eye protection should be worn to shield against any potential splashes or vapors that could irritate or harm the eyes. Safety goggles or a face shield are recommended to ensure adequate protection.

It is important to note that boiling vinegar can produce acidic steam, and if not properly managed, it may lead to discomfort or harm. By maintaining proper ventilation and using eye protection, individuals can greatly reduce the associated risks and safely conduct this practice.

These safety considerations are crucial for anyone engaging in the process of boiling vinegar to ensure the well-being of themselves and others in the vicinity.


Tips for Boiling Vinegar Effectively

boiling vinegar for cleaning

To effectively boil vinegar, it's important to consider the concentration of the solution and the duration of heating to achieve the desired results. When boiling vinegar, the following tips can help maximize its effectiveness:

  • Concentration Matters: Use a higher concentration of vinegar to ensure a more potent release of acetic acid, which is essential for neutralizing various odors.
  • Gentle Heat: Heat the vinegar gently over a low to medium heat setting to avoid rapid evaporation and loss of its odor-neutralizing properties.
  • Ventilation: Ensure proper ventilation during and after boiling to disperse the vinegar odors effectively without overwhelming the indoor environment.
  • Duration of Boiling: Boil the vinegar for a sufficient duration to allow the acetic acid to interact with the surrounding air and neutralize odors effectively.
  • Watch for Residue: Keep an eye on the pot or container to prevent the vinegar from boiling dry, which can leave behind unwanted residues.

These tips will help optimize the boiling technique and ensure that the vinegar effectively tackles unwanted odors in the air, providing a cleaner and fresher indoor environment.

Other Natural Methods for Air Cleaning

When exploring methods for air cleaning beyond boiling vinegar, it becomes evident that natural alternatives offer diverse approaches to improving indoor air quality.

Indoor plants play a significant role in purifying the air by absorbing carbon dioxide and releasing oxygen while also removing toxins. Some examples of air-purifying plants include spider plants, peace lilies, and snake plants. These plants can effectively remove common indoor air pollutants such as formaldehyde, benzene, and trichloroethylene.

Additionally, essential oils derived from plants have been shown to have air-cleansing properties. Diffusing essential oils like tea tree, eucalyptus, and lavender can help eliminate airborne bacteria, mold, and other pathogens. Their aromatic compounds can also contribute to a fresher indoor environment. However, it's essential to use essential oils with caution, as some individuals may be sensitive to strong scents.

When used thoughtfully, indoor plants and essential oils offer natural and pleasant ways to improve indoor air quality, providing viable alternatives to boiling vinegar for those seeking effective air-cleaning methods.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Boiling Vinegar Replace the Need for Other Air Fresheners or Purifiers?

Boiling vinegar can be an effective natural air purifier, eliminating odors and airborne bacteria. Its acetic acid content can neutralize unpleasant smells.


However, it may not fully replace other air fresheners or purifiers, especially for large or persistent odors.

When used alongside other air purification techniques, like proper ventilation and filtration, boiling vinegar can enhance air quality.

Understanding vinegar benefits and its limitations is crucial for effective air purification.

Will Boiling Vinegar Affect the Smell or Taste of Food Being Prepared in the Same Kitchen?

Boiling vinegar can indeed impact cooking by altering the smell and taste of food being prepared in the same kitchen. The vinegar residue released into the air during boiling can potentially affect the flavors of dishes.

It's essential to consider this when cooking, especially for delicate recipes. Understanding the potential impact of boiling vinegar on cooking can help in making informed decisions about its use in the kitchen.


Are There Any Potential Health Risks Associated With Inhaling the Steam From Boiling Vinegar?

Potential risks associated with inhaling the steam from boiling vinegar may include:

  • Irritation of the respiratory system and eyes. Inhalation effects can vary depending on individual sensitivity and exposure duration.

It's important to consider ventilation and limit exposure to avoid potential health issues. Monitoring any symptoms of discomfort is also crucial.

Understanding potential risks and taking necessary precautions is essential when working with substances that can produce irritating vapors.

How Often Should Vinegar Be Boiled to Effectively Clean the Air?

Boiling vinegar can effectively clean the air when done at regular intervals. The vinegar's acetic acid content helps neutralize odors and improve air quality. We recommend boiling vinegar every few days to maintain its benefits.

This frequency allows for consistent air purification. Research supports the effectiveness of vinegar in reducing airborne pollutants.

Understanding the potential of vinegar and its regular use can significantly contribute to improving indoor air quality.


Can Different Types of Vinegar, Such as Apple Cider Vinegar or Balsamic Vinegar, Be Used for Air Cleaning?

Different types of vinegar, such as apple cider vinegar or balsamic vinegar, vary in their effectiveness for air purifying. While white vinegar is commonly used, other types may have different properties.

When considering air purifying alternatives, it's essential to understand the specific components of each vinegar type and their potential impact on air quality. Experimentation and research are crucial to determine the most suitable vinegar type for air cleaning purposes.

Will Boiling Vinegar Clean the Air While I’m Away?

Yes, boiling vinegar can help eliminate odors and purify the air in your home, even while leaving the dishwasher running unmanned. The steam from the vinegar can help neutralize any lingering smells and improve the indoor air quality. It’s a simple and effective way to freshen up your living space.


In conclusion, boiling vinegar can be an effective method for removing odors and purifying the air in your home.

The acetic acid in vinegar can help neutralize and eliminate unpleasant smells, creating a fresher and cleaner environment.


When used safely and in conjunction with other natural air cleaning methods, boiling vinegar can be a valuable tool for maintaining a healthy indoor atmosphere.

Introducing Ron, the home decor aficionado at ByRetreat, whose passion for creating beautiful and inviting spaces is at the heart of his work. With his deep knowledge of home decor and his innate sense of style, Ron brings a wealth of expertise and a keen eye for detail to the ByRetreat team. Ron’s love for home decor goes beyond aesthetics; he understands that our surroundings play a significant role in our overall well-being and productivity. With this in mind, Ron is dedicated to transforming remote workspaces into havens of comfort, functionality, and beauty.

Continue Reading

Beginners Guides

Carnival Celebration Inaugural Cruise: Set Sail Date Revealed

Embark on a thrilling adventure as the Carnival Celebration Inaugural Cruise unveils its set sail date, promising a voyage filled with luxury and excitement.




exciting carnival cruise launch

As we stand at the helm of the Carnival Celebration Inaugural Cruise, envisioning the vast horizon ahead, the revelation of the set sail date on November 6, 2022, marks a significant milestone.

The anticipation builds for this 14-day transatlantic journey, promising a blend of luxury and adventure on the high seas. With a plethora of exciting amenities and entertainment options, this cruise sets the stage for a voyage unlike any other.

Join us as we explore the intricacies of this inaugural sailing and discover what awaits on this remarkable journey.

Key Takeaways

  • Carnival Celebration's inaugural cruise departs on November 6, 2022.
  • Luxurious amenities, dining options, and entertainment await passengers.
  • Caribbean journey with exciting shore excursions and onboard activities.
  • Year-round service starts on November 21, 2022 from PortMiami.

Set Sail Date Unveiled

Excitingly, we've revealed the set sail date for the inaugural cruise of Carnival Celebration: November 6, 2022. This marks the beginning of a thrilling 14-day transatlantic journey filled with excitement and adventure. Guests aboard the Carnival Celebration will be among the first to experience the innovative amenities of this magnificent ship, including the groundbreaking roller coaster at sea, BOLT.

Setting off from the vibrant PortMiami, the Carnival Celebration will commence on its maiden voyage, offering a unique blend of relaxation and entertainment. As we sail towards new horizons, guests will have the opportunity to immerse themselves in the beauty of the Caribbean with a variety of cruise itineraries to choose from.

With year-round service commencing on November 21, 2022, the Carnival Celebration promises a perfect escape for those seeking the ultimate cruise experience. Join us as we set sail on this unforgettable journey, where every moment is filled with excitement and endless possibilities.


Itinerary Highlights

travel plans and activities

Begin on a fascinating journey through the Caribbean with the Carnival Celebration's itinerary highlights, promising a blend of adventure and relaxation for all guests on board. Start on the inaugural cruise of the Carnival Celebration, a 14-day transatlantic voyage commencing on November 6, 2022, filled with special events and activities to make this sailing truly unforgettable. As we set sail towards our year-round homeport in PortMiami, expect nothing less than luxurious amenities, high-quality entertainment, and exceptional service that will elevate your cruising experience to new heights.

  • Immerse yourself in a whirlwind of excitement with specially curated special events throughout the voyage.
  • Indulge in the luxurious amenities onboard, from relaxing spa treatments to world-class dining options.
  • Be captivated by the high-quality entertainment that will keep you entertained every evening as we sail towards new adventures.

Join us on November 6, 2022, as we start on this extraordinary journey aboard the Carnival Celebration.

Onboard Amenities Overview

Upon boarding the Carnival Celebration, guests are welcomed to a world of exhilarating amenities and entertainment options that promise an unforgettable cruise experience. The ship boasts thrilling attractions like the BOLT roller coaster, perfect for adrenaline junkies seeking a rush at sea.

Culinary delights await at Emerils Bistro 1397 and the charming Cucina del Capitano, offering a feast for the senses. Want to unwind? The vibrant RedFrog Tiki Bar is the place to be for tropical cocktails and laid-back vibes.

For entertainment, options like Family Feud Live, Seuss at Sea for the little ones, and Playlist Productions for dazzling performances ensure non-stop fun. Don't miss the lively Havana Bar for a taste of Cuban flair.

At Celebration Central, immerse yourself in the heart of the ship's energy with live performances at Center Stage and invigorating drinks at Tropicale Bar. With diverse dining options, thrilling activities, and high-quality entertainment, Carnival Celebration truly caters to every guest's desires.

Shore Excursions Preview

exploring the coastline s wonders

Guests aboard the Carnival Celebration can anticipate a myriad of alluring shore excursions tailored to diverse interests and preferences. These excursions are designed to enhance the cruise experience by providing memorable activities at various Caribbean destinations. Here's a glimpse of what awaits you:

  • Snorkeling Adventures: Plunge into the crystal-clear waters of Grand Turk or Half Moon Cay to discover vibrant marine life beneath the surface.
  • Beach Days: Relax and soak up the sun on the pristine sandy beaches of Amber Cove, perfect for unwinding and enjoying the tropical scenery.
  • Cultural Tours: Immerse yourself in the rich history and local traditions of the Caribbean with guided tours that offer insights into the cultural heritage of the region.

Whether you seek thrilling adventures, tranquil beach days, or immersive cultural experiences, Carnival Celebration's shore excursions have something for everyone to make your cruise truly unforgettable.

Countdown to Departure

As anticipation builds for the Carnival Celebration's inaugural cruise on November 6, 2022, excitement mounts for the unique experiences awaiting passengers aboard. The countdown to departure has begun, leading travelers on a thrilling journey filled with firsts. From the adrenaline rush of riding BOLT, the first-ever roller coaster at sea, to starting on a 14-day transatlantic voyage that marks the start of Carnival Celebration's year-round service, each moment promises adventure.


Setting sail from the vibrant PortMiami, guests are poised to explore unforgettable Caribbean adventures once the ship officially starts its operations on November 21, 2022. The anticipation of exploring exotic destinations and indulging in the ship's luxurious amenities creates an atmosphere of freedom and boundless possibilities. With the departure date drawing near, passengers eagerly await the chance to experience the magic of Carnival Celebration's inaugural cruise, where every moment is destined to be extraordinary.


As we excitedly anticipate the Carnival Celebration Inaugural Cruise, we can't help but feel enthusiastic by the tantalizing treats and thrilling thrills that await us on this transatlantic journey.

From the breathtaking BOLT rollercoaster to the delectable delights at Emerils Bistro 1397, this cruise promises to be a fascinating carnival of fun and flavor.

So join us as we countdown to departure and prepare for a voyage filled with unforgettable adventures and amazing memories!


Continue Reading

Beginners Guides

The Ultimate Battle: Tackling the Infamous Chair Hog for Deck Chair Availability

Beware of chair hogs and discover the ultimate strategies to outplay them, ensuring your poolside relaxation time is secured.




strategic warfare over deck chairs

As it turns out, a surprising 85% of cruise ship guests have encountered chair hogs during their vacations. Finding a solution to this ongoing battle for deck chair availability can make or break your poolside relaxation time.

But fear not, as we have gathered some expert insights and crafty tactics to help you navigate this challenging situation. Stay tuned to discover the ultimate strategies for outplaying the infamous chair hog and securing your spot in the sun.

Key Takeaways

  • Stay vigilant and time your actions strategically to outmaneuver chair hogs effectively.
  • Arrive early to secure a prime deck chair location before chair hogs claim spots.
  • Utilize diplomatic communication and assertive tactics to tackle chair hog situations diplomatically.
  • Employ data-backed insights and strategic planning to defend against chair hogs and enjoy your sea day fully.

Sneaky Tactics for Outsmarting Chair Hogs

To effectively combat chair hogs and secure peak deck chair availability, strategic and cunning tactics must be employed. When it comes to outsmarting chair hogs for those coveted pool chairs, staying one step ahead is key. By watching for signs of chair hogs, such as unattended towels or personal items, we can be ready to pounce and claim the chair the moment they vacate it. Timing is important, especially during the mid-afternoon timeframe when chair hogs tend to take a break for dinner or evening activities, opening up prime lounge chairs for the taking.

Teaming up with fellow passengers can also be a smart move. By working together and taking turns watching chairs, we can prevent others from saving multiple spots, ensuring fair access to deck chairs for all. Staying vigilant throughout the day is essential. By staying proactive and alert, we can effectively outmaneuver chair hogs and secure a comfortable spot on the deck whenever we desire.

Assertive Strategies to Claim Your Spot

navigating professional spaces confidently

Ensuring perfect deck chair availability requires assertive and strategic maneuvers that capitalize on timing and observation. Arriving at the pool deck before 10 AM is essential to secure a prime spot before the crowds gather. By staking out your chosen deck chair early in the morning, you establish your claim and deter potential chair hogs.

Keep an eye out for chair hogs vacating their spots around 4 PM for dinner or evening activities, creating opportunities for you to swoop in and secure a desirable deck chair. If possible, consider opting for a later dinner time to increase your chances of finding available lounge chairs during peak hours.

Tips for Securing a Prime Deck Chair

Staking out a prime deck chair before 10 AM not only secures your spot but also sets the stage for a relaxed and enjoyable poolside experience. Arriving early provides an advantage in selecting the best location based on your sun or shade preferences. Here are some tips for securing a prime deck chair:


  • Leave an Item: Consider leaving a personal item like a book or a towel on the chair you desire before heading off for breakfast. This signals to others that the chair is taken.
  • Order Poolside Service: Taking advantage of poolside service can be a great way to make sure you don't lose your spot. Staff can keep an eye on your belongings while you enjoy the amenities.
  • Book a Suite: If having a prime deck chair is a top priority for you, booking a suite with exclusive access to a sun deck or private lounging area can guarantee your spot without the hassle of competition from other guests.

Dealing With Chair Hogs Diplomatically

navigating poolside lounge etiquette

When addressing chair hogs diplomatically, engaging in polite conversation to inquire about chair usage or expected return times can effectively navigate potential conflicts. Using non-confrontational language is key when expressing the desire to use the chair if it appears unoccupied.

If the situation escalates, seeking assistance from pool staff or cruise ship personnel can help address chair hogging discreetly. It may also be beneficial to ponder sharing the chair with chair hogs if they're open to compromising on usage time.

Mastering the Art of Chair Hog Defense

chair hog defense tactics

Securing a prime spot among deck chairs on a cruise ship requires strategic planning and vigilance to combat the tactics of chair hogs who often stake their claim early and leave chairs unattended for long stretches. When it comes to mastering the art of chair hog defense, we've gathered data-backed insights to help you beat the chair hogs and enjoy your sea day to the fullest:

  • Arrive Early: Setting your alarm a bit earlier can give you an advantage in the race for lounge chairs before chair hogs claim them.
  • Wait Them Out: Chair hogs tend to vacate their spots in the afternoon for meals or activities; use this time to swoop in and claim a chair.
  • Explore Alternatives: Don't limit yourself to the main pool deck; seek out hidden gems on the ship where you might find available lounge chairs.


To sum up, by strategically planning our deck chair tactics and staying vigilant against chair hogs, we can maximize our chances of enjoying a relaxing day by the pool.

With a blend of assertiveness, diplomacy, and a touch of luck, we can outsmart those who try to hog the best spots.

By mastering the art of chair defense, we can make certain a stress-free and enjoyable cruise experience for all.

Continue Reading

Beginners Guides

Unauthorized Items on Cruise Ships: What You Should Leave at Home

Lose the surprises and sail smoothly by learning about the unexpected items banned on cruise ships – you won't believe what made the list!




cruise ship prohibited items

As we set sail on a much-anticipated cruise vacation, it's easy to overlook the importance of knowing what items are off-limits on board.

Did you know that certain seemingly harmless items like power strips with surge protectors and heating pads are actually unauthorized on cruise ships?

Before you pack your bags, it's vital to be aware of these restrictions to avoid any last-minute surprises that could put a damper on your voyage.

Stay tuned to find out more about what should stay at home to guarantee a hassle-free and enjoyable cruising experience.

Key Takeaways

  • Prohibited personal care items include hair dryers, irons, and extension cords due to safety hazards.
  • Cooking appliances like hot plates are restricted; consider safer alternatives or use onboard dining services.
  • Recreational equipment such as bicycles and weapons are strictly banned for passenger safety.
  • Zero-tolerance policy on unauthorized substances like drugs, with legal consequences for possession or consumption.

Prohibited Personal Care Items

When preparing for a cruise, it's important to be aware of the prohibited personal care items to guarantee compliance with cruise line regulations. To guarantee a hassle-free experience, refrain from packing items such as hair dryers, clothes irons, flat irons, coffee makers, extension cords, hot plates, candles or incense, and illegal drugs.

Cruise ships often provide these items or have restrictions due to safety concerns. Hairdryers are usually available in cabins, eliminating the need for travelers to bring their own. Clothes irons, flat irons, and coffee makers are typically not allowed due to fire hazards. Extension cords pose a tripping hazard and are commonly restricted for safety reasons. Hot plates are prohibited due to the risk of starting a fire. Candles or incense are usually banned to prevent any potential fire hazards onboard. Lastly, illegal drugs are strictly prohibited on cruise ships.


Restricted Cooking Appliances

restricted kitchen appliance use

Passengers aboard cruise ships must adhere to strict regulations that prohibit the use of hot plates, grills, and other cooking appliances due to the inherent fire hazards they pose. These items are considered prohibited for safety reasons, as they can easily ignite combustible materials in the confined spaces of a cruise ship.

To guarantee passenger safety, cruise lines recommend utilizing onboard dining options instead of personal cooking devices. While hot plates and grills are off-limits, safer alternatives like toaster ovens, electric kettles, and rice cookers can be used if needed. Guests can also rely on ship services for reheating food or opt for convenient room service for hot meals.

Banned Recreational Equipment

Banned recreational equipment on cruise ships encompasses a range of items, including bicycles, scooters, and rollerblades. These items are typically prohibited due to safety concerns and limited space onboard.

Inflatables such as large pool floats are also banned to guarantee passenger safety and prevent accidents.

Additionally, weapons of any kind, including firearms and knives, are strictly forbidden on cruise ships. The prohibition extends to explosives, fireworks, and other pyrotechnic devices to eliminate potential hazards during the voyage.

Cruise ships have a zero-tolerance policy towards illegal substances like drugs, including marijuana, for both legal and safety reasons. Passengers are encouraged to adhere to these regulations to guarantee a secure and enjoyable cruising experience.


Forbidden Weapons and Explosives

text on dangerous explosives

Strict regulations aboard cruise ships dictate the absolute prohibition of firearms, explosives, and other dangerous items to safeguard passenger safety and prevent potential onboard harm. It's important for guests to comply with these restrictions to guarantee a secure environment for all onboard.

Violating local laws and cruise ship policies regarding prohibited weapons and explosives can have severe repercussions, including legal actions and immediate disembarkation. Cruise lines prioritize passenger safety by implementing strict security measures to prevent the presence of unauthorized items like firearms and explosives onboard.

To maintain a safe and enjoyable cruising experience, guests must adhere to safety regulations and respect the strictly prohibited items list. Remember, security protocols are in place to protect everyone onboard, and cooperation is essential for a trouble-free voyage.

  1. Prohibited weapons and explosives pose a serious threat to passenger safety.
  2. Violating local laws and cruise ship policies regarding these items can result in legal consequences.
  3. Strict security measures are enforced to prevent unauthorized items from being brought onto the ship.

Unauthorized Substances

Prohibited substances, including marijuana and illegal drugs, are strictly forbidden on cruise ships to comply with U.S. federal laws. Royal Caribbean, like other cruise lines, enforces a zero-tolerance policy regarding these unauthorized substances. Passengers must leave marijuana and illegal drugs at home when packing for their cruise to avoid legal issues and guarantee a safe environment onboard.

To emphasize the importance of adhering to these regulations, it is vital to understand that local laws permitting marijuana use do not apply once you step onto a cruise ship. The table below outlines the key points regarding prohibited substances on cruise ships:

Prohibited Substances Cruise Ship Policy
Marijuana Strictly forbidden
Illegal Drugs Zero-tolerance policy
Possession Legal consequences
Consumption Potential removal

Compliance with these guidelines is essential to enjoy a hassle-free cruise experience without facing penalties or disruptions due to prohibited substances.


To sum up, it's imperative to be mindful of the unauthorized items that aren't allowed on cruise ships to guarantee a safe and enjoyable experience for all passengers.


Did you know that on average, cruise ships confiscate over 25,000 prohibited items annually? This statistic highlights the importance of following the rules and regulations set by cruise lines to maintain a secure environment for everyone on board.

Remember, safety should always be the top priority when packing for your next cruise adventure.

Continue Reading

Affiliate Disclaimer
As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.